B-Booking prop firms

Trading
1

Which prop firms give accrual accounts. Is it more beneficial to have a B-boking prop firm or is there a point at which it becomes more beneficial to be A-booking. Which is more sustainable. Should there be an algorithm to determine if a trader got lucky?

2 Likes
2

A-Book Prop Firm (Agency Model)

How It Works:

  • In an A-book model, the firm acts as an intermediary, passing all client trades directly to the market or a liquidity provider. The firm earns money through commissions or spreads rather than trading against the client.
  • The firm doesn’t take any market risk itself, as it simply routes orders to the market.
  • Client profit equals firm profit, as the firm’s revenue is based on transaction volume.

Benefits for Traders:
*Transparency: Traders’ orders are executed at real market prices, often leading to better pricing and execution.
*No Conflict of Interest: Since the firm doesn’t take the opposite side of the trade, there’s no incentive to see traders lose.

B-Book Prop Firm (Market Maker Model)

How It Works:

  • In a B-book model, the firm itself takes the opposite side of the client trades, meaning it doesn’t pass the trades onto the market but holds them in-house.
  • The firm profits when the trader loses and loses when the trader profits.
  • The firm may hedge its overall risk by managing the exposure of multiple clients together.

Benefits for Traders:
*Potentially Lower Costs: B-book firms might offer tighter spreads or lower fees since they control the execution.
*Higher Flexibility: Some B-book firms may offer more leverage or flexible trading conditions.

Which is More Beneficial for Traders?

A-Book Firms:
*Pros: Generally better for traders who seek transparency and fair market execution without worrying about conflicts of interest. Experienced traders who can consistently profit might prefer this model because they don’t have to worry about the firm working against them.
*Cons: May have slightly higher costs in terms of spreads or commissions due to passing trades to the market.

B-Book Firms:
*Pros: May offer lower costs and more lenient conditions, which can be attractive for beginners or those with smaller accounts.
*Cons: There is a potential conflict of interest, as the firm benefits when the trader loses. Some traders might experience issues with order execution, slippage, or withdrawal delays.

Conclusion:

*A-Book firms are generally more beneficial for serious traders who value transparency and a direct connection to the market.

*B-Book firms might appeal to traders looking for lower costs or those who are still learning, but they should be cautious of the potential conflicts of interest.

Some Examples of prop firms:

  1. A-book prop firms: 5%ers, Audacity Capital, BluFX, TopstepTrader
  2. A-book prop firms: FTMO (with some A-Book characteristics), SurgeTrader, Funding Pips, FundedNext, E8 Markets.